Cheap Overwater Bungalows is supported by its audience. When you purchase through links on our site, we may earn an affiliate commission at no extra cost to you.
If you’re on the East Coast and longing for a tropical escape, you might be wondering if there are any closest overwater bungalows to New York that don’t require a 15-hour flight. The good news is that there are a few incredible options located in the Caribbean and Central America, all reachable in just a few hours by plane.
From crystal-clear waters to luxurious amenities, overwater bungalows offer the perfect combination of privacy and paradise. Let’s dive in and explore what you need to know before booking your stay.
But before we go any further, we have to acknowledge the hard work that our team has put in to get the best overwater bungalow data out there. We have meticulously created and maintain our list of every overwater bungalow in the world.
Having a hold on this data helps our special algorithm to constantly browse and find hidden deals and anomalies in pricing. We use this to create new content like you are reading right now, and also to feed into our weekly overwater bungalow deals newsletter. We highly recommend signing up to be involved with the best overwater bungalow deals.
Best Time of the Year to Visit the Tropics
When planning a getaway to enjoy the closest overwater bungalows to New York, timing matters. Generally, the tropics have two main seasons: the wet season (often May to November) and the dry season (December to April). The dry season usually brings more sunshine and calmer seas, which can make your overwater villa experience even more idyllic.
However, traveling in the off-season can sometimes mean lower rates and fewer tourists—just be mindful of hurricane season in the Caribbean, typically June to November. If you’re flexible with your travel dates, keep an eye on weather patterns and resort promotions, as you could snag a great deal and still enjoy relatively good weather.
The List of Closest Overwater Villas
Below, we’ve highlighted some of the top picks for the closest overwater bungalows to New York, each offering its own unique twist on the luxurious over-the-water experience.
One thing to note is that these are sorted by cheapest to most expensive, not exactly closest first! We just want to save you money.
EI Faro del Colibri – $124+ Per Night
Book here if you care about: Compact hotel walking distance to restaurants and a marina
Experience the charm of Bocas Del Toro, at the delightful EI Faro del Colibri. 5 Overwater bungalows close to Bocas Town. The best time to visit is during the high season, November – April, while the quieter low season is May – October. With each season offering something special, this place remains a perfect year-round getaway.
Anthonys Key Resort – $267+ Per Night
Book here if you care about: Private island overwater bungalows in a scuba diving paradise
Located on the colorful island of Roatan in the Caribbean, Anthonys Key Resort invites guests to enjoy a unique local experience. Private island style overwater bungalows in Roatan Honduras. The best time to visit is during the high season, December – April, while the quieter low season is May – November. Visitors can enjoy distinct seasonal activities, making any visit a rich experience.
Mango Creek Lodge – $400+ Per Night
Book here if you care about: Fishing or diving in Roatan Honduras
Mango Creek Lodge provides a perfect gateway to explore the wonders of Roatan, Caribbean. Colorful overwater bungalows with a focus on diving and fishing. The best time to visit is during the high season, December – April, while the quieter low season is May – November. Whether you come in the peak or off-peak season, this location promises memorable adventures.
Lina Point Belize Overwater Resort – $599+ Per Night
Book here if you care about: Fishing, scuba diving, and other tropical watersports
Set on a barrier reef in Belize in the Caribbean, at the delightful Lina Point Belize Overwater Resort. Unique location for fishing and watersports. The best time to visit is during the high season, December – April, while the quieter low season is May – November. Whether you come in the peak or off-peak season, this location promises memorable adventures.
Banyan Tree Mayakoba – $883+ Per Night
Book here if you care about: Established 5 star resort with select overwater bungalows in man made lagoon
Explore the natural beauty of Yucatan at Banyan Tree Mayakoba, located in the heart of Mexico. Mayakoba seclusion and luxury with wonderful restaurants. The best time to visit is during the high season, December – April, while the quieter low season is May – November. This destination is ideal for those who appreciate both vibrant and tranquil travel experiences.
Nayara Bocas del Toro – $1,200+ Per Night
Book here if you care about: 16 Luxury overwater bungalows with outstanding service
Set in the stunning landscape of Bocas Del Toro, Nayara Bocas del Toro offers an exclusive escape from the ordinary. The only 5 star overwater bungalow resort in Bocas Del Toro. The best time to visit is during the high season, November – April, while the quieter low season is May – October. This destination is ideal for those who appreciate both vibrant and tranquil travel experiences.
Rosewood Mayakoba – $1,500+ Per Night
Book here if you care about: Well known Rosewood brand and outstanding food
Located in the vibrant Yucatan of Mexico, Rosewood Mayakoba invites guests to enjoy a unique local experience. Mayakoba luxury and exclusivity meets delicious food and highly trained staff. The best time to visit is during the high season, December – April, while the quieter low season is May – November. With each season offering something special, this place remains a perfect year-round getaway.
h2>Palafitos Overwater Bungalows – $1,900+ Per Night
Book here if you care about: Luxury overwater bungalows near Cancun
Embrace the serene environment of Yucatan, Mexico, by staying at Palafitos Overwater Bungalows, where comfort meets culture. The only luxury overwater bungalows near Cancun. The best time to visit is during the high season, December – April, while the quieter low season is May – November. Explore the essence of Mexico through its seasonal contrasts and superb hospitality at Palafitos Overwater Bungalows.
Sandals Royal Caribbean – $3,500+ Per Night
Book here if you care about: Ultra luxury all inclusive resort with private island and restaurants
Sandals Royal Caribbean in Jamaica, Caribbean, is a perfect blend of comfort and authentic local experiences. The only overwater bungalows in Montego Bay. The best time to visit is during the high season, December – April, while the quieter low season is May – November. Each visit offers a chance to experience new aspects of Jamaica, making it ideal for repeat visits.
Sandals South Coast – $3,500+ Per Night
Book here if you care about: Super exclusive resort with a price to match
Prepare for a convenient experience in Jamaica at Sandals South Coast, located in the heart of the Caribbean. The only overwater bungalows in south Jamaica. The best time to visit is during the high season, December – April, while the quieter low season is May – November. The seasonal dynamics here offer varied experiences, suitable for different travel preferences.
Disney’s Polynesian Village Resort – Price Not Available
Book here if you care about: If you like overpaying for Disney and don’t care about water clarity
Uncover the hidden gems of Orlando, United States, at Disney’s Polynesian Village Resort, where each stay turns into a memorable experience. Polynesian style overwater bungalows on a manmade lake at Disney World Orlando. The best time to visit is during the high season, June – August, while the quieter low season is September – May. Each visit offers a chance to experience new aspects of Orlando, making it ideal for repeat visits.
Closest Overwater Bungalows to New York: Conclusion
Ultimately, the closest overwater bungalows to New York combine the dream of living over crystal-clear waters with the convenience of shorter travel times. Whether you choose the luxurious suites in Jamaica, the eco-friendly lodges of Belize, or the cultural allure of Mexico’s Riviera Maya, you’ll find that these tropical escapes offer a blissful retreat from city life.
By timing your trip wisely and selecting the perfect resort for your preferences, you can turn the idea of an overwater bungalow vacation into a reality—without spending endless hours in transit. Start planning today, and your next postcard-worthy experience could be just around the corner!
And as always, be sure to stay tuned to Cheap Overwater Bungalows to stay up to date.
